Parent-as-borrower vs. student-as-borrower

It's natural to want to take care of your child. It's also natural to balk at paying tens of thousands of dollars (maybe more) for his college education. The dilemma gets more complicated when you think, “If I can't afford tuition, how can a student right out of high school afford it?” And what if you have more than one college-bound child?

Once awards and scholarships have been accepted and the accountants consulted, many families turn to education loans to meet the Expected Family Contribution (EFC). But who should get these loans: the student or the parent?

If the student borrows …

Chances are your 18- to 22-year-old doesn't have much of a credit history or the income required to qualify for a traditional consumer loan. That’s OK, because consumer loans aren’t ideal ways to pay for college. School-certified student loans, however, are built for the student (or parent) borrower, with lenient credit eligibility, lucrative tax benefits, and forgiving repayment terms.

If your child takes a student loan, the first ones he chooses should be federal Stafford loans. With a low, fixed interest rate of 6.8% and no payments required until after graduation, it's no wonder they are the most common student loans. The downside is that Stafford loans carry annual borrowing limits that often aren’t high enough to cover a year of college.

A supplemental student loan is a private or alternative education loan that is school-certified. These loans allow students to borrow up to the cost of attendance (minus other aid). There are eligibility requirements, but private student loans are accessible and affordable financing options for students.

Private student loans give students the option of concentrating on their studies and the “college experience” instead of taking a job throughout their college years. During repayment, they’ll be able to take a tax deduction for interest paid on qualified student loans.

If the parent borrows …

College loans for parents are a little bit different than those for students. While there are federally and privately guaranteed varieties, the eligibility requirements and repayment terms are designed for the more experienced borrower.

A parent who borrows money for school should look into federal Parent PLUS loans first. Contrary to popular misconception, a borrower cannot be turned down for earning too much (or too little). A parent of a dependent undergraduate need only be creditworthy and meet U.S. citizenship requirements.

If parents are ineligible to borrow PLUS loans, like students, they should consider private or alternative education loans. The Sallie Mae Smart Option Student Loan is an ideal education funding solution if you still need funds after maximizing grants, scholarships, and federal loans.

The advantages of parents borrowing either federal or private loans include tax deductions for interest paid on qualified loans, and no aggregate borrowing limit (so you can finance all your children in school).

Education loans for parents carry repayment terms that differ from loans for students. While parents can often choose a repayment schedule, there is no automatic deferral until the student leaves school; that is, repayment begins immediately.

The bottom line …

Paying for college is a lasting financial commitment, and the only way to determine the right course of action is to evaluate your family’s circumstances and short-, mid-, and long-term goals. Sallie Mae's Education Investment Planner can help you evaluate your situation.

You may choose to employ one, some, or all of the above loan to cover college costs. And you can get creative: Some families have students take Stafford loans and the parents pay them down; conversely, some parents unofficially turn over PLUS loan payments to their kids once they’re out of school. (Remember, whoever applied for the loan is responsible for repaying it!)

Student loans are good debt. Not only are they investments, but they can earn the borrower tax advantages and rewards from a lender. Who takes the risks and the ultimate spoils is up to you and your child.


  • Favorites
  • Google
  • Yahoo Bookmarks
  • delicious
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Facebook

Proponents of the student-as-borrower scenario could make the following points:

The student is the beneficiary of the loan, and therefore should bear the sacrifices associated with the loan.

The student can use the student loan to build credit history.

The student can learn how to manage debt obligations responsibly.

Parent-as-borrower champions might say:

The cost of education is the whole family’s financial burden to bear, not just that of the student. For example, the Student Aid Report indicates EFC, not expected student contribution.

Parents have greater borrowing power, which may earn more favorable loan terms than those students could qualify for.

Parents may be able to benefit more than students can from the tax advantages of student loans.


© 1995–2010 Sallie Mae, Inc. All rights reserved. Our trademarks | Terms of use | Protecting your privacy | Avoid online fraud

SLM Corporation and its subsidiaries are not sponsored by or agencies of the United States of America.